MapsGuide Jen had noted in the Google Group – Maps for Business that the bulk upload had been fixed as of January 4th. That “fact” was reported here and at SearchEngine Roundtable. However according to recent posts in the Group (here and here) it appears that the bulk upload feature is still not working. This feature has been missing in action since approximately December 20th.
Over this past year one of my most frequently read articles was Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps (Nov 2006)I decided to revisit the current data (Thanks to Miriam at SeoIgloo) to see which directories Google was using for the restaurant industry and to see how things had changed. I also realized that this might provide some baseline data to answer the question of whether Google’s relationship with CitySearch had changed.Google Maps attempts to gather authoritative details of a local business by crawling & parsing the semi-structured data of on-line directories (see also Bill Slawskiâ€™s patent summary). The restaurant industry is one of the industries that clearly benefits from local search. I have analyzed the local listings of the first 16 restaurants listed in the Buffalo, NY market and summarized which on-line directories Google is currently using and compared them to those used in November of 2006. There are some interesting differences.
|Directory||Jan 2008 # Listings||Nov 2006 # Listings|
|More from 10best.com Â»||11||3|
|More from Allmenus.com Â»||6||Â|
|More from ChefMoz.org Â»||7||3|
|More from DiningGuide.com Â»||1||4|
|More from Frommers.com Â»||4||2|
|More from Gayot.com Â»||9||4|
|More from JiWire.com Â»||1||2|
|Provided by the business owner||1||1|
|More from RestaurantRow.com Â»||10||7|
|More from SuperPages.com Â»||3||5|
|More from Talkingphonebook.com Â»||1||2|
|More from Wcities.com Â»||17||7|
|No Longer in Restaurant Listings||Â||Â|
Some observations and notes and additional findings: Continue reading Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps – 2008
Update 7:14 am 01/08/08 MapsGuide Jen to stay!
I’m not going anywhere quite yet! You’ll be seeing more posts from Maps
Guide Sirene in the group, but you can’t get rid of me that easily ;o)
Well Dave, there is a Santa Claus after all!
In a surprise announcement today, it was noted that Maps Guide Serene will be answering questions in the Google Maps for Business Group. This appears to be one of those good news bad news arrangements where Maps Guide Jen finally received the help she so desparately needed. However, it seems that Mapsguide Jen is being replaced as our intrepid interpreter and mystic seer of the cryptic meanderings of Google Maps. It appears that Maps Guide Jen has either been promoted or moved on.
I like to think that it is the former. And I will forever more think of Jen as MapsGod Jen. In related news it has been announced that a foundation may be set up in her name.
MapsGod Jen will forever be remebered for her hard work,a steady hand at the helm and equanimity in the face of duress and and an angry mob..
Taking Local Search to Store Shelves – Greg Sterling, Screenwerks
Google on Reading Text in Images from Street Views, Store Shelves, and Museum Interiors – Bill Slawski, SeobytheSea
Googlebot In Aisle Three: How Google Plans to Index the World? – Bill Slawski, SearchEngineLand
Mobile User Survey Redux: the Late Adopter
After Greg Sterling surveyed SEL readers on their mobile internet usage patterns, I thought it would be interesting to survey a totally distinct user group. Greg agreed and we surveyed the 1123 registered readers of OleanInfo.com, a local portal site catering to folks interested in Olean NY. Roughly 80% of OleanInfo’s readership lives within 40 miles of Olean, NY, a small town in western NY State.
The readership was chosen for contrast with the SEL readers. Presumably they are rural or of rural origins and less technically oriented. They proved to be, as a group, classic “late adopters”. 85.8% of the OleanInfo respondents were over 40 and 58% over 50 and as a group had very low mobile internet use. This stood in contrast to the SEL readership that was 84% under 40 of which almost half access the mobile internet once per week or more.
â€¢ 90% of respondents report using their cells to text message (thus they do sooner or later adopt)
â€¢ 0% penetration of the iPhone
â€¢ Very low (12%) penetration of traditional smartphones
â€¢ 87% had no mobile internet usage AT ALL
â€¢ 26% reported using Free DA and of those 32% used Goog-411 and 44% uses Free-411. (Remember that the Goog-411 billboard campaign took place in Olean)
Here are the results of the survey taken last week. OleanInfo respondents are listed first with the comparable SEL response in parenthesis.
What sort of mobile phone do you currently own?
- Conventional cell phone — 87.6% (58.7%)
- Traditional smartphone (e.g., BlackBerry, Treo) — 12.4% (30.7%)
- iPhone — 0.0% (10.7%)
Indicate how many of the following you do with your mobile phone (multiple answers permitted):
- Send and receive text/SMS messages — 90.9% ( 97.2%)
- Access the mobile Internet — 22.7% (56.9%)
- Use downloaded applications (e.g., Mapquest Navigator, Google Maps for Mobile) — 12.1% (36.1%)
How frequently do you access the mobile Internet?
- Never — 87.2% (33.8%)
- Once a month or less — 4.6% (13.5%)
- Two-three times a month â€“ 4.6% (5.4%)
- More than once a week — 1.8% (21.6%)
- At least once daily â€“ 1.8% (25.7%)
If you don’t access the Internet on your mobile phone, why not (multiple answers permitted)?
- Keying in queries is frustrating — 21% (45%)
- The network is too slow — 6.2% (52.5%)
- The screen on my phone is too small — 14.8% (57.5%)
- I don’t have a mobile Internet plan — 77.8% (45%)
Which of the following mobile search engines/sites do you use (multiple answers permitted)?
- Ask â€“ 17.4% (8%)
- AOL â€“ 4.3% (0%)
- Google â€“ 78.3% (90%)
- Microsoft Live Search/MSN â€“ 26.1% (8%)
- Yahoo oneSearch/Go â€“ 41.3% (20%)
- Note-The high response rate on this question implies that the question was not fully understood
Do you use any of the free directory assistance options?
- Yes â€“ 26% (29%)
- No â€“ 74% (71%)
If you use any of the free directory assistance options, which one(s):
- Goog411 — 32% (73.9%)
- 1-800-YellowPages (AT&T) â€“ 28% (8.7%)
- 1-800-Call-411 (Microsoft) â€“ 12.0% (8.7%)
- 1-800-Free-411 â€“ 44% (21.7%)
Indicate your gender
- Female â€“ 38% (24%)
- Male — 62% (76%)
Indicate your age
- 18-24 — 1.8% (17.3%)
- 25-30 — 2.7% (25.3%)
- 31-40 — 9.8% (41.3%)
- 41-50 — 27.7% (12%)
- 51-60 — 30.4% (4%)
- Over 60 — 27.7% (0%)
Where do you reside?
- US/North America — 99.1% (65.3%)
- Europe — 0.9% (25.3%)
- Asia — 0.0% (9.3%)
The survey has the caveats of any internet survey and the results only reflect the reality of the group surveyed. That being said these responses provide an interesting contrast to the results of the SEL reader survey.
Here are the top 10 read articles from Understanding Google Maps over the past 12 months:
1. Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps
2. First Case of Large Scale Abuse at Google Maps
3. Google Coupons now has searchable interface
4. Now taking Nominations for the Rubber Chicken Awards
5. Sources for Google Mapâ€™s Restaurant Local Listing data
6. Goog-411 Rolls out Billboards in the Hinterlands
7. Subscribe to Google Coupons
8. What does a link campaign look like for Local?
9. Has Google relationship with CitySearch changed
10. Yahoo Mapspam now appearing near you
WhatsOpen is an intriguing service with an even more intriguing about us page. Their approach to local search is not the standard who, what or where but rather what and when. They ask a question that even folks familiar with their own local scene frequently ask.
Just type in the name of the store youâ€™re looking for, and your location….Results are displayed on a Google Map mashup, with listing of stores, their hours of operation, their phone numbers and their distance from the city center appearing in a left-hand column.
Users choosing to sign up for the full beta of the version get access to information from the U.S., the European Union and China along with mobile phone applications Google Android or iPhone.
An interesting report of agressive marketing & billing practices in the Local SEM space in the Google Maps for Business Group.
In Restless Pursuit of Craigslistâ€™s Success – Bob Tedeschi, NY Times
The NY Times writes a glowing report about The Kijiji unit of eBay in their pursuit of Craig’s List. At the end of the article Kijiji’s opportunities were put in perspective by Greg Sterling:
Even without such features, though, Craigslist added nearly seven million users during the last year. That should be enough to give pause to Kijiji and other competitors, according to Greg Sterling, of Sterling Market Intelligence, an advertising consultancy. â€œThere are other sites, like Google Base, with nicer features for users, but they havenâ€™t dented Craigslist,â€ he said.
Windows Live Expo from Microsoft, another free classified ad site, has also struggled to gain an audience. â€œThe more competition there is, the more it reinforces Craigslistâ€™s users,â€ Mr. Sterling said. â€œSo Kijiji is going to have to take a long-term view if they want to gain any traction.â€
Some days it seems like the World and Google Maps are going to hell in a hand basket with intractable problems; Global warming, end of oil, the war in Iraq, mapspam etc… but I am one of those folks that is a pessimist of mind and an optimist of heart about world affairs. I see the problems, note them (perhaps too often for friends and family alike) but firmly believe that humanity can solve them. At least I have hope that we can.
The same goes for Google. I may seem like a classic kvetcher when it comes to Google. Complain, complain, complain you say, never anything good to say… However the complaints that I have noted about Google Maps just reflect my desire for them to succeed. I really want local to work and I (in my heart of hearts) am rooting for Google to be one of the companies* that sucessfully pushes local into our lives.
In fact, it was but a little more than a year ago that Bill Slawski and I did a little “Jane, you ignorant slut”** two step where I took the side that (Google) Local would improve in accuracy over time while Bill contended that the task was too daunting and that data accuracy would not significantly improve.
I really do want Google Maps to succeed so I am making a New Years Budget Resolution for Google: Hire MapsGuide Jen some help! Heck what does a good customer service rep cost in San Jose? $60,000 a year? That’s but 100 shares of Google stock. Alternatively they could ground the plane for a week. It would go a long way towards showing that Google does intend “goodwill toward small business people and peace on (Google) Earth & Maps” for 2008.
Continue reading 2008 Wishes: Peace on earth, goodwill for all people and help for MapsGuide Jen
Update 01/04/08 According to MapsGod Jen this has now been fixed. Jen has apparently been on leave and yesterday returned to the Google Maps for Business Group with a vengeance!
In today’s Google Maps For Business Owners another bug in the Local Business Center seems to have been confirmed. This time the bulk upload procedure seems to have broken and has been so since at least Dec. 20th:
TOPIC: Error 504
== 1 of 3 ==
Date: Fri, Dec 28 2007 10:08 am
I believe you are also refering to my recent question with the same problem. Has anyone else experienced this, and are there any recommendations on what could be causing this?
On Dec 27, 3:24 pm, “m.storagefacil…@gmail.com”
> I noticed around the 22nd of Dec that I haven’t been able to upload
> bulk feed as well. I keep getting this Error. It isnt Just me, as
> im seeing that others are experiencing the same problem. Is there a fix?
== 2 of 3 ==
Date: Fri, Dec 28 2007 10:30 am
Oh Im wrong it is a 502 server error. Whats the fix? I dont know
but I hope someone from google looks at this blog so that we can get
back to work.
== 3 of 3 ==
Date: Fri, Dec 28 2007 2:54 pm
I am having the exact same issue – I have been trying to upload my unicode text file since Dec. 20th without success.
Perhaps the Google Local Business Center is undergoing renovations, perhaps Mapsquide Jen is on an extended holiday break (she deserves it) but the problems of customer service, mapspam, broken coupons and now the broken upload feature seem to be piling up in the forum and have gone unanswered for an extended period.
Our newest blog, Small linux deployments, is all about the technical side of operating a local linux-based hosting and web design company and is written by Erek Dyskant.
Erek is our System analyst, sys admin, programmer, hardware and general technical guru, a sort of Renaissance man of the Linux world. He has worked with us, off and on, since he was 16 and is both a great co-worker and a good friend.
He is a unique package that emdodies the big view of technology, the detailed view of the hardware & software and the ability to communicate about it to geeks AND small business folks. He’s a good coder to boot, studies biology and has a detailed understanding of national and global politics. If you run a small linux based hosting company or just are interested in the details of doing so take a look at Erek’s blog, you will find it an interesting read.