Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps – 2008

Over this past year one of my most frequently read articles was Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps (Nov 2006)I decided to revisit the current data (Thanks to Miriam at SeoIgloo) to see which directories Google was using for the restaurant industry and to see how things had changed. I also realized that this might provide some baseline data to answer the question of whether Google’s relationship with CitySearch had changed.Google Maps attempts to gather authoritative details of a local business by crawling & parsing the semi-structured data of on-line directories (see also Bill Slawski’s patent summary). The restaurant industry is one of the industries that clearly benefits from local search. I have analyzed the local listings of the first 16 restaurants listed in the Buffalo, NY market and summarized which on-line directories Google is currently using and compared them to those used in November of 2006. There are some interesting differences.

Directory Jan 2008 # Listings Nov 2006 # Listings
More from 10best.com » 11 3
More from Allmenus.com » 6  
More from ChefMoz.org » 7 3
More from DiningGuide.com » 1 4
More from Frommers.com » 4 2
More from Gayot.com » 9 4
More from JiWire.com » 1 2
Provided by the business owner 1 1
More from RestaurantRow.com » 10 7
More from SuperPages.com » 3 5
More from Talkingphonebook.com » 1 2
More from Wcities.com » 17 7
     
No Longer in Restaurant Listings    
Citysearch.com   10
Hotelguide.net   3
Marriott.com   1
MobilTravelGuide.com   1
Mytravelguide.com   2
Sidestep.com   2
Travelocity.com   3

Some observations and notes and additional findings:All of the listings were of locally owned restaurants and unlike last year there were no chain restaurants or hotels in the top 16 listings – a distinct improvement in listing qualityOnly one restaurant had edited their own business listing. While this is the same as last year, last year it was a hotel that had done so. In that very limited sense, restaurant’s have just barely started to control their own records.There was one new restaurant directory being referenced: Allmenus.com with 6 entriesThere were 7 directories that were no longer referenced in the restaurant listings. Six of those directories were hotel specific directories. With the improved quality and focus of the restaurant listings, it is understandable why they were not being used.CitySearch.com was no longer being used as a reference directory by Google. This compliments the reports of their reviews disappearing and appears to confirm that they are gone from Maps.SuperPages is listed with less frequency than last year.Note the difference in the OneBoxes from Nov ’06 and Now:restbuffwmapcomparison.jpg

Please consider leaving a comment as your input will help me (& everyone else) better understand and learn about local.
Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps - 2008 by

5 thoughts on “Which On-line Directories provide details to Google Maps – 2008”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Comments links could be nofollow free.