Understanding Google My Business & Local Search
Which Terms Trigger the New Entertainment Pack
The new carousel replacement, like the carousel, shows for entertainment and recreational searches. This entertainment pack almost always (but not quite always) starts at position one right below any ads. I wanted to see which terms that previously showed the Carousel were now showing the new Entertainment Pack.
When the original local Carousel first came out in June of 2013, we were able to identify a list of 350 terms that produced a local carousel. I tested a sampling of 50 of those terms to see which results were now showing the new entertainment pack.
I ran 100 searches with my location set to New York, NY (to be sure that there was always enough inventory) and searched on 50 terms both with and without NYC as a geo modifier.
33 of the 50 geo modified search terms now showed the entertainment pack instead of the carousel. Of the Non Geo modified terms 29 now showed the new pack. Thus of the 100 searches that originally showed carousels, 52% were showing the new display. Of the 48 that weren’t showing the new pack, 17 were showing a traditional pinned pack of some sort (1,3, 5 and 7). Of those 17, 5 appeared to be branded packs results.
In 3 of the 100 searches performed, the new Entertainment Pack showed in position two on the page. So while it usually shows in the first position below the ads, that is not always case. Once it showed below a definition, once below an image result and once below a website result with site links. This was the case only on non geo modified queries.
Ypou are welcome to test some of the terms that generated the original carousel to see if they are now generating the new Enterntainment Pack. Here is the spreadsheet with the search phrases.
Here’s the summary of the results:
Old Carousel | Carousel Replacement w/o geo modifier | Notes | CR w/ geo modifer "NYC" | Notes |
Accommodations | Not showing | Shows 7 pack | not showing | |
Entertainment Club | Not showing | not showing | ||
video | Not showing | not showing | ||
alcohol | Not showing | 3 Pack | ||
alleys | Showing | Shows below definition | 1 Pack | |
American Food Ca | Showing | Showing | ||
American Restaur | Showing | Showing | ||
amusement | Not showing | Showing | ||
Amusement Center | Showing | Shows below Images | Showing | |
Amusement parks | Not showing | KG Carousel showing | not showing | KG carousel showing |
Arcades | Showing | Showing | ||
art | Not showing | Shows 7 Pack | not showing | |
Art galleries | Showing | Showing | ||
Art Gallery | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian | Not showing | Shows 7 Pack | Showing | |
Asian Cuisine | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Delivery | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Food | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Grocer | Showing | Position 2 | Showing | |
Asian Market | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Restaurant | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Supermarket | Showing | Showing | ||
Asian Take Out | Showing | Showing | ||
Attractions | Showing | Not showing | KG carousel showi | |
Auditorium | Not showing | Shows 7 Pack | Showing | |
Authentic French | Not showing | Not showing | ||
Authentic French | Not showing | Not showing | ||
Bagels | Showing | Showing | ||
Bakeries | Showing | Showing | ||
ballrooms | Showing | Showing | ||
Banquet Hall | Showing | Showing | ||
Barbecue Catering | Not showing | Showing | ||
Bars | Showing | Showing | ||
BBQ | Not showing | Branded 3 Pack | Showing | |
BBQ Restaurant | Not showing | Branded 3 Pack | Not showing | Branded 3 Pack |
BBQ Ribs Restaur | Not showing | 1 Box | Not showing | |
Beach Motel | Showing | Showing | ||
Beach Resort | Not showing | Showing | ||
Beachfront Weddin | Not showing | Not showing | ||
Bed & Breakfast | Not showing | Shows 5 pack | Not showing | Shows 7 pack |
B & B | Not showing | Branded 7 pack | Not showing | Shows branded 7 |
Beer | Showing | Showing | ||
billiards | Showing | Showing | ||
Boat Charter Servi | Not showing | Not showing | Shows 7 Pack | |
bowling | Showing | Showing | ||
Box Lunch Supplie | Not showing | Showing | ||
Breakfast | Not showing | Shows 7 pack | Not showing | Shows 1 Pack |
Breakfast Restaur | Showing | Showing | ||
brew pub restaura | Showing | Showing | ||
Breweries | Showing | Showing |
© Copyright 2024 - MIKE BLUMENTHAL, ALL RIGHT RESERVED.
Comments
3 Comments
Thanks Mike – very useful.
I have a question about ordering of results in the new format. I’m not seeing them match up against new maps results – is this expected and is this a function of the algo or is there an inventory aspect at play too?
Thanks for doing all this research Mike!
Myles,
In limited testing this morning, using the longer data combination I wrote about here:
!3m1!4b1!4m5!2m4!3m3
at the end of the maps /am=t URL
seems to be generating results that are awfully darn close to the new pack results.
Comments for this post are closed.